Two tools dominate conversations about digital wishlists. Amazon Wishlist is the one most people have used at least once — it's built into the world's largest online shop, so the path of least resistance leads straight to it. Giftster is the other name that comes up, particularly among families in the US who want a shared list system that works across multiple people.
Neither was built with UK shoppers in mind. Amazon Wishlist is inherently Amazon-shaped. Giftster is functional but American by design. If you want a wishlist that genuinely works across the British high street and beyond — Boots, John Lewis, Argos, ASOS, Etsy, independent shops — both options start to show their limits quickly.
Here's an honest look at what each tool does well, where it falls short, and what a UK-built alternative looks like in practice.
Amazon Wishlist does exactly what it says. You browse Amazon, click “Add to List”, and the item lands on a shareable page that anyone can view. It's fast, it's familiar, and for items sold on Amazon it works without friction.
The trouble starts the moment you want something that isn't on Amazon. A specific candle from a small UK maker. A book from a specialist bookseller. A jacket from a brand that doesn't wholesale through Amazon. You can technically add external items using a browser extension, but the experience is inconsistent — images break, prices don't update, and items often appear as bare links rather than proper cards.
There are a few other quirks worth knowing. Amazon has historically had issues with purchase visibility: in some configurations, the person whose list it is can see which items have been bought and by whom before the occasion arrives. Amazon has worked to address this, but the behaviour has been unreliable enough over the years that it remains a common complaint. More structurally, everyone involved needs an Amazon account — gifters who don't use Amazon regularly will have to create one just to mark something as taken care of.
It's also worth noting that Amazon Wishlist nudges everything toward Amazon fulfilment. If the same item exists on Amazon and from an independent retailer, the list naturally gravitates toward the Amazon version. For people who care where their money goes, that's a meaningful constraint.
Giftster takes a different approach. Rather than being tied to a single retailer, it's designed around family groups — everyone in a family creates a list, and the group can coordinate who's buying what for whom. It's a genuinely useful idea, and for US families it has a decent following.
For UK users, though, it feels like using an app designed for a different country. The currency and retailer assumptions are American. Some features that seem core — certain group functions, advanced privacy controls — sit behind a paid tier. Adding items from UK shops involves either a browser extension that doesn't always behave or manual entry, which means typing in names, prices, and URLs by hand.
There's nothing fundamentally wrong with Giftster. It solves a real problem for the audience it was built for. But that audience isn't primarily British shoppers wanting to add items from their local Waitrose, a Notonthehighstreet seller, or a favourite independent clothing brand. The tool works around that limitation rather than removing it.
The best wishlist isn't tied to where you shop. It's tied to what you want.
When you ask people in the UK what they actually want from a wishlist tool, the answers are consistent. They want to add items from wherever they shop — not just Amazon, not just the big chains, but the full range of places British shoppers actually buy things. That means Boots and Superdrug for beauty. John Lewis and M&S for homewares. ASOS, & Other Stories, Reiss for clothes. Waterstones for books. Independent shops, Etsy sellers, Notonthehighstreet. The list is long because British retail is genuinely varied.
They want prices displayed in pounds. They want gifters to be able to browse and coordinate without necessarily needing their own account on some American platform. And they want some confidence that the person receiving the gifts won't inadvertently see what they're getting before the occasion arrives.
These aren't unusual requirements. They're just not well served by tools that were built for a different market.
gift it is built around the principle that a wishlist should be retailer-agnostic. You add items by pasting a URL from any shop, scanning a barcode on your phone, or entering details manually. The item appears as a proper card — image, name, price in pounds, link back to the retailer — regardless of where it came from. A John Lewis lamp sits next to an Etsy print sits next to a book from Waterstones, all on the same list.
It's free to use. There's no premium tier for basic wishlist functions. Gifters can browse a shared list without creating an account — they only need a free account if they want to mark something as taken care of, which prevents duplicates. That marking is invisible to the person whose list it is until the occasion date has passed, so there are no accidental spoilers.
gift it is a UK product, built with British shoppers and British retail in mind. Prices are in pounds. The retailer universe isn't artificially limited.
Retailer scope. Amazon Wishlist works reliably only for Amazon. Giftster supports external items but with friction. gift it accepts any shop via URL or barcode, with no meaningful restriction.
UK pricing. Amazon shows GBP for UK accounts. Giftster defaults to USD and requires manual conversion for many items. gift it pulls prices in pounds from UK retailers as standard.
Gifter account requirement. Amazon requires gifters to have an Amazon account. Giftster requires a Giftster account to view lists. gift it lets anyone browse with just a link; an account is only needed to mark items.
Recipient privacy. Amazon's purchase visibility has been inconsistent historically. gift it hides all gifter activity from the recipient until after the occasion, without exception.
Cost. Amazon Wishlist is free. Giftster has a free tier with limitations and a paid upgrade. gift it is fully free, funded by affiliate commission on purchases made through list links.
gift it earns a small affiliate commission when gifts are bought through links on a list. This is disclosed on every page of the site. It never influences what appears on anyone's list — the tool works identically whether an item comes from a retailer with an affiliate programme or one without.
There's no import tool — you can't connect your Amazon Wishlist or Giftster account and have everything transfer automatically. In practice, rebuilding a list takes around ten minutes. You paste each item's URL into gift it, the details populate from the retailer page, and you're done. If an item is on Amazon and you'd rather keep it there, that works too — paste the Amazon URL and it appears on your gift it list as normal, with the Amazon link intact for gifters who prefer to buy there.
The rebuild is a small one-off cost. Most people who switch find it worth doing once, then update the list incrementally from that point forward — adding new items as they come across things they like, rather than maintaining a separate list elsewhere.
These tools aren't mutually exclusive, and each has genuine strengths. If you buy almost everything from Amazon and your gifters are comfortable on that platform, Amazon Wishlist does the job without any additional setup. If you're part of a large extended family in the US that already uses Giftster together, changing platforms introduces unnecessary disruption.
But if you shop across a range of UK retailers, want gifters to be able to coordinate without friction, and don't want to worry about accidental spoilers or Amazon account requirements, gift it is built for exactly that. It's a tool designed around how people in the UK actually shop and give — which, for most people reading this, is the more useful starting point.
Add items from any shop and share one link with everyone buying for you.
Create your list